Skip to main content
Back to the journal
Market Updates

Florida’s Big Investor Exit: Hundreds Of Homes Hitting The Market With Some Selling Over 100k Less Than Their 2021 Purchases

Troy Nowak
November 19, 2026
21 min read
Troy Nowak, Real Estate Broker at Mangrove Bay RealtyTroy NowakReal Estate Broker · Mangrove Bay RealtyAirbnb Superhost · STR SpecialistMap of corporate-owned rental homes from Tampa Bay to Orlando, with the homes listed for sale now glowing red

Zillow says home prices here are up since 2021. So why is one of America's largest investors listing a Riverview home for $130,100 less than it paid in 2022?

I pulled the county records for 329 single-family homes owned by institutional rental companies between Tampa and Orlando, and checked every one against Zillow on November 19, 2026. Then I went to the MLS and pulled the full listing and sale history for the 203 of them owned by LLCs named HP, HPA and HPRV.

These aren't distressed homeowners. They're professional investors who renovated the homes, rented them out, and are now putting them back on the market. Here's what the records show.

The short version

  • 98 of the 329 homes are listed for sale right now. 66 have already cut the price.
  • Nearly the whole portfolio is on the market. Of the 200 homes held by the LLCs named HP and HPA, 195 were listed for sale, put under contract or sold in the last six months.
  • Homes they bought before 2021 are fine. The typical one is asking about 50% more than they paid.
  • Homes they bought in 2021 to 2023 are not. The typical one is asking about 11% less than they paid, and some are 15% to 28% under.
  • It's not just asking prices. All 8 homes these owners bought in 2022 and sold in the last six months closed below what they paid. The typical one sold for 12% less.
  • Of the 189 homes these owners put on the MLS, 133 (70%) cut the price at least once. 77 are under contract.

The market didn't crash. By Zillow's index, counties here are 5% to 10% off their recent peaks. But the same house, bought at the top and sold today, can be down 15% to 28%. The headline numbers hide that.

Four homes corporate landlords bought in 2022, with the purchase price, today's price and the loss on each: Riverview down $130,100, Deltona down $90,000, Ormond Beach down $84,000 and Tampa down $76,100

The receipts: real homes, real numbers

Every purchase price below is on a recorded deed. Every sale or asking price is from the MLS.

Check your area:

Already sold, below what they paid. The eight biggest losses among closed sales in the MLS, matched to the purchase price on the deed. Of the 15 homes these owners bought from 2021 to 2023 and sold in the last six months, 13 closed below what they paid, including all 8 bought in 2022.

AddressBoughtPaidSold forClosedDifference
1098 E De Carlo Dr, DeltonaJul 2022$335,000$245,000Nov 2026-$90,000 (27%)
483 Spruceview Dr, Port OrangeAug 2022$364,800$290,000Oct 2026-$74,800 (21%)
1081 55th Ter S, St. PetersburgJul 2023$475,000$403,000Oct 2026-$72,000 (15%)
10662 Park Meadowbrooke Dr, RiverviewJan 2023$371,300$310,000Nov 2026-$61,300 (17%)
4610 Sloan Ave, SarasotaAug 2021$262,000$204,900Sep 2026-$57,100 (22%)
34 Ocean Pines Dr, Ormond BeachMay 2022$410,000$355,000Nov 2026-$55,000 (13%)
824 Radcliff St, DeltonaOct 2022$220,800$174,900Oct 2026-$45,900 (21%)
4038 Langsom Ln, North PortSep 2021$314,000$275,000Nov 2026-$39,000 (12%)

Listed or under contract right now, below what they paid.

AddressStatusBoughtPaidAsking nowDifference
12721 Standbridge Dr, RiverviewActiveJun 2022$459,000$328,900-$130,100 (28%)
463 River Square Ln, Ormond BeachPendingMay 2022$424,000$340,000-$84,000 (20%)
1217 E Norfolk St, TampaActiveJun 2022$496,000$419,900-$76,100 (15%)
321 Alexzander Way, Winter HavenActiveMar 2022$400,000$325,000-$75,000 (19%)
5107 Coddington St, OrlandoPendingMay 2022$445,000$374,900-$70,100 (16%)
1028 Appian Pl, Wesley ChapelActiveMay 2023$505,000$435,000-$70,000 (14%)
1716 Watrous Dr, TitusvilleActiveJul 2022$360,000$299,900-$60,100 (17%)
922 Glazebrook Loop, Orange CityPendingJun 2022$425,000$365,900-$59,100 (14%)
2021 Harvest Landing Cir, LakelandActiveSep 2022$358,100$299,900-$58,200 (16%)
1511 Sweet Apple St, OaklandPendingSep 2022$373,500$320,000-$53,500 (14%)
7977 49th Ave N, St. PetersburgPendingSep 2021$445,000$397,500-$47,500 (11%)

Click any address to see the home on Zillow. Prices are as of November 19, 2026. Asking prices on active and pending homes are not final sale prices.

The same comparison against the whole city: Zillow's index has the typical St. Petersburg home up 13% since September 2021, the month this one was bought.

Chart: Zillow's home value index for St. Petersburg is up 13% from September 2021 to October 2026, while 7977 49th Ave N, bought new in September 2021 for $445,000, is under contract at an asking price of $397,500, down 11%

Dumbbell chart of 11 homes corporate landlords bought from 2021 to 2023, showing purchase price in gray and today's asking price in red, from 11% to 28% below cost

Now the other side of the same portfolio. The 32 homes these owners bought before 2021 and sold in the last six months closed for a median 57% more than they paid. Not one sold below cost.

Bar chart of closed sales by purchase year: homes bought before 2021 sold a median 57% above cost, 2021 buys 4% below, 2022 buys 12% below, and 2023 buys 15% below

Same owners. Same market. The only real difference is when they bought.

Where the 98 listings are

CountyCorporate-owned homes listed
Pinellas22
Hillsborough18
Orange13
Seminole9
Polk7
Manatee6
Pasco5
Hernando, Osceola and Volusia4 each
Lake and Sarasota2 each
Brevard and Lee1 each

They stopped renting these homes and started selling them

I searched the county records for every home owned by the LLCs named HP and HPA, then matched each one to the MLS. Of 200 homes, 195 (97.5%) were listed for sale, put under contract or sold between May and November 2026: 66 active, 76 under contract and 53 sold. Only 5 show no sale activity.

The listing history shows when it changed. New MLS listings on these homes, by year:

YearListed for rentListed for sale
2022200
2023150
2024230
2025362
20267185

Through 2025 these homes kept going back up for rent. In 2026 that stopped. From April through mid-November there were 3 new rental listings on these homes and 178 new for-sale listings.

Three limits on that number:

  • It covers the LLC names I searched. The same parent company may own more homes under other names.
  • It is one landlord. The other big group in the county records, LLCs with "SFR Borrower" in the name, has about half of its 129 homes listed or recently sold.
  • Not every rental is advertised on the MLS, so the rental counts are a floor.

Why the headline number can fool you

Most market reports lead with the median sale price. That's the middle price of the homes that sold that month. It is not what your home is worth.

The median moves when the mix of buyers moves. If first-time buyers get priced out by rates and insurance, fewer starter homes sell. The homes that do sell skew bigger, newer and more expensive. The median goes up even if no single home gained a dollar.

The better test is one home. Bought updated or brand new in 2021 or 2022. Nothing done to it since. Sold today. Did it sell for more or less than it cost? These landlords just ran that test for us: same house, same condition, two prices.

Here is what the wider market did over the same years. Zillow Home Value Index, typical home, by county:

CountyJune 2021June 2022October 2026Since 2021Since 2022
Pinellas$309,852$393,638$369,630+19.3%-6.1%
Hillsborough$298,262$393,441$374,327+25.5%-4.9%
Pasco$267,221$353,232$326,163+22.1%-7.7%
Polk$240,655$313,606$293,960+22.2%-6.3%
Orange$313,583$394,457$398,751+27.2%+1.1%
Volusia$264,493$334,774$323,377+22.3%-3.4%

Source: Zillow Research, ZHVI by county, all homes, mid tier, smoothed and seasonally adjusted.

Line chart of the Zillow Home Value Index for Orange, Hillsborough, Pinellas and Polk counties from 2019 to October 2026, rising sharply through mid-2022 and flat to down since

Built from Zillow Research's county data. The shaded band is when the 2021 to 2023 homes in this story were bought.

A home bought in June 2022 in Hillsborough would be down about 5% today if it tracked the county. The Riverview home at the top of the list is asking 28% under its purchase price.

Who owns these homes, and why now

The 203 homes in the MLS data are owned by LLCs with names like HPA US1 LLC, HPA III Acquisitions 1 LLC and HP Florida I LLC. On the Pinellas County property appraiser's site, HPA US1 LLC's tax bills go to 120 S Riverside Plaza, Suite 2000, in Chicago. That was the headquarters of Home Partners of America, a rent-to-own landlord, until Blackstone moved to close the office in 2025 (The Real Deal).

Blackstone bought Home Partners in June 2021 for about $6 billion, when it owned more than 17,000 homes (Axios). In 2024, Blackstone began folding Home Partners into Tricon Residential, another Blackstone company, with Tricon taking over its homes and leases (Commercial Observer).

The timing fits the data. Most of the homes now listing below cost were bought in 2021 and 2022, right after the Blackstone deal, at the top of the market.

The pressure to sell is national. On November 17, 2026, Hedgeweek reported that activist investor Land & Buildings is pushing Invitation Homes, the largest single-family landlord in the country, to sell homes one at a time and return at least $2 billion a year to shareholders. Their argument: the stock values each home at about $270,000, while the company's own sales since December 2025 have averaged about $460,000.

Invitation Homes is a different company from the one in my data, but it shows the scale. It wholly owned 85,961 homes on September 30, 2026. 26,539 of them, about 31%, are in Florida: 9,594 in Tampa, 7,746 in South Florida, 7,073 in Orlando and 2,126 in Jacksonville (SEC filing). Tampa is its biggest Florida market. In the third quarter of 2026 alone, it sold 658 homes and bought 216.

Why would they sell at a loss?

One piece is on the record. Blackstone began folding Home Partners into Tricon in 2024. Neither company has said the homes would be sold, but the listings show it. When a platform is being absorbed, homes that don't fit the new owner's plan get sold, including the ones that lost money.

The rest I can't see inside their books, so these are likely reasons, not facts:

  1. Selling is worth more than holding. For the public landlords, the stock market values their homes for less than the homes sell for one at a time. When that gap is big, selling houses and buying back stock beats keeping every house.
  2. Holding costs kept rising. These homes don't get a homestead exemption. The typical tax bill in this group is about $6,300 a year. Add insurance, repairs and turnover, and a home bought at a 2022 price may not cover its costs at today's rents.
  3. The loans come due. Many of the owner names include "Borrower" and a year, like "SFR II Borrower 2021-3 LLC." That naming usually means the homes back a pooled loan. When those loans mature, owners refinance or sell.
  4. Rents stopped climbing. The rent growth that justified 2022 prices slowed down.

For the HP and HPA homes, the handover to Tricon is the likeliest explanation. Nearly every one of them is on the market or already sold, older homes at big gains and peak-year homes at losses. Across the rest of the industry it doesn't look like panic. Invitation Homes still reports 96.4% same-store occupancy.

How this compares to 2008

2006 to 2012 crashToday
Tampa Bay and Orlando county values, peak to bottomDown 49% to 55%Down 5% to 10% from the recent peak
Who's selling below costHomeowners and banks, through foreclosures and short salesBig landlords, by choice, on homes bought at the 2022 peak
WhyBad loans, job losses, forced salesPortfolio decisions, holding costs
ForeclosuresA floodNot a wave in this data

County figures are from Zillow's home value index: Pinellas fell 49% from September 2006 to January 2012, Hillsborough 49%, Orange 55% and Volusia 54%.

The dollar gaps today look scary, $50,000 to $130,000 on single homes. But a 12% to 28% loss on homes bought at the very top is a different thing from the whole market losing half its value. The one place in Florida closer to a real decline is Lee County, around Fort Myers, which is down about 19% from its 2022 peak.

The new federal law on big landlords

The 21st Century ROAD to Housing Act became law on July 11, 2026. It defines a "large institutional investor" as a for-profit company that controls 350 or more single-family homes. Starting January 7, 2027, those companies can't buy more existing single-family homes, with exceptions for things like build-to-rent and rehab projects (CNBC, Latham & Watkins).

It does not force anyone to sell. Homes they already own are grandfathered. So the law isn't why these homes are listed below cost. Most of these listings started before the ban takes effect, and the Home Partners handover to Tricon began in 2024.

What the law changes is the direction. Big landlords can sell existing homes but, after January 7, they mostly can't buy them back. That makes these sales a one-way door.

What this does to rents

Every home a big landlord sells to a family is one less house for rent. Under the new law, most of those houses won't be replaced with other existing homes.

Single-family rents in Tampa Bay are already climbing faster than apartment rents. On Zillow's rent index, the typical Tampa single-family rent is $2,359 a month. That's up 34% since June 2021 and 11.5% since June 2022, while home values are down about 6% since June 2022. Rents for all Tampa rentals, apartments included, are up only 5.2% since June 2022 (Zillow Research).

My read on where this goes, and it's a forecast, not a fact:

  • More homeowners. Some renters will buy the homes these landlords sell, often at better prices than in 2022.
  • Higher rents for houses. Families who need a yard and three bedrooms but can't buy will compete for fewer rental houses. In neighborhoods where these landlords own a lot of homes, expect house rents to keep rising faster than apartment rents.
  • Apartments cushion it. Rent growth has slowed to about 1.6% in the past year for Tampa single-family homes, and new apartments and build-to-rent communities are still being built. That keeps a lid on how fast rents can climb.

For landlords who own a few houses, fewer corporate competitors and steady demand for rental houses is good news. For renters, house rents are more likely to drift up than down.

What this means for you

If you're buying: homes corporate owners bought in 2022 and 2023 are where the negotiating room is. Two out of three of these listings have already cut the price. A big owner with dozens of listings and repeated cuts is a motivated seller. Ask what the owner paid. It's public record on the county property appraiser's site. Selling below what they paid doesn't always mean selling below market value, so check the comps.

If you bought in 2022: your home is probably not down as much as these. The county indexes say most areas are 5% to 10% off the peak. But if one of these sells near you, it becomes a comp. Check before you list or refinance.

If you're selling: price to today's sales, not to 2022. Buyers can look up these numbers too.

If you flip houses: be careful in these neighborhoods. Your after-repair value comes from recent sales. When a large owner lists a renovated house $60,000 or more under its 2022 price, and then cuts it again, that sale becomes the comp for your flip. Pull the institutional listings within a mile before you buy, and underwrite to their price, not last year's.

If you're investing: the old math was "Florida only goes up." Since 2021 it has. Since 2022 it hasn't. The purchase price decides most of the outcome.

The hidden play: taking over a neighbor's 3% mortgage

Look at the loans on the homes around these listings. If corporate homes are selling below 2021 prices, a lot of the owners next door who bought in 2021 have little or no equity. Many of them also have FHA or VA loans at 3% or less, and those loans can be assumable.

When the seller has almost no equity, a buyer may be able to take over that low-rate loan with little cash beyond closing costs. A few things to know first:

  • The buyer has to qualify with the loan servicer, and assumptions often take two to four months.
  • Anyone can assume a VA loan, but the seller's VA entitlement stays tied to it unless the buyer is a veteran who substitutes theirs.
  • If the seller owes more than the home is worth, someone has to cover the gap, or the lender has to agree to a short sale.

Watch for short sales and foreclosures, too. No equity on its own doesn't cause a foreclosure. Most of these owners have fixed payments they can keep making. But if someone in that position loses a job, divorces or has to move, they can't sell their way out. That's when short sales and foreclosures show up, and lower comps from big sellers make it more likely.

The more likely result for most 2021 and 2022 buyers isn't foreclosure. It's slower sales, lower appraisals and more price cuts on their own homes when they do sell. That hurts, but it's not 2008.

What to watch next

  • January 7, 2027. The federal ban on big landlords buying existing homes takes effect. Watch whether sales pick up before or after.
  • The activist push. If Invitation Homes agrees to sell homes much faster, more corporate listings will hit Tampa Bay, where it owns about 9,600 homes.
  • Appraisals and refinances. When these below-cost listings close, they become comps. Owners nearby who bought in 2022 may see lower appraisals, which limits cash-out refinances.
  • Rentals turning into for-sale homes. In neighborhoods with a cluster of these listings, that adds supply fast.
  • The last of the HP and HPA homes. With 195 of 200 already listed, under contract or sold, watch how fast the rest sell and at what prices.

Frequently asked questions

Are institutional landlords selling Tampa Bay homes below cost?

Some are. In the MLS, all 8 homes these owners bought in 2022 and sold in the last six months closed below what they paid, a median of 12% less. A Deltona home bought for $335,000 in 2022 sold for $245,000 in November 2026. And one Riverview home is listed $130,100 under its June 2022 price.

Who owns the homes selling below cost?

LLCs named HPA, HP and HPRV, such as HPA US1 LLC and HP Florida I LLC. County records mail their tax bills to the former Chicago headquarters of Home Partners of America, a rent-to-own landlord Blackstone bought in 2021 and began folding into Tricon Residential in 2024.

How many Invitation Homes are in Florida?

On September 30, 2026, Invitation Homes wholly owned 85,961 homes nationwide. About 31% of them, 26,539 homes, were in Florida, with 9,594 in Tampa, its largest Florida market.

How much are 2021 to 2023 purchases down?

Closed sales: 2022 purchases sold for a median 12% below what the owners paid, and 2023 purchases 15% below. Listings: the typical home bought from 2021 to 2023 is asking about 11% less than its purchase price, with the biggest gaps around 15% to 28%. Homes the same owners bought before 2021 sold for a median 57% more than they paid.

Why would a landlord sell a home at a loss?

The likely reasons are rising holding costs (taxes, insurance and repairs on homes without a homestead exemption), pooled loans coming due, cleaning up the portfolio, and rents that stopped climbing. Those are likely reasons based on the public data, not statements from the owners.

Is the Tampa Bay housing market crashing?

No. Zillow's index has every Florida county above its June 2021 level, and Tampa Bay counties are about 5% to 10% below their recent peaks. The losses in this story come from buying at the top, not from a crash.

Does the new federal law force big landlords to sell?

No. The ROAD to Housing Act stops companies with 350 or more single-family homes from buying more existing homes starting January 7, 2027, with exceptions like build-to-rent. Homes they already own are grandfathered. They can keep them or sell them.

Will rents go up?

Rents for houses likely will. Each home a big landlord sells to a buyer is one less rental house, and under the new law most won't be replaced. Tampa single-family rents are already up 11.5% since June 2022, faster than apartments, though growth slowed to about 1.6% in the past year.

How does this compare to 2008?

From 2006 to 2012, Tampa Bay and Orlando county home values fell 49% to 55% on Zillow's index, driven by bad loans and forced sales. Today those counties are 5% to 10% off their recent peak, and the below-cost sales are landlords choosing to sell homes bought at the top.

Will this cause more foreclosures?

Not on its own. No equity doesn't force a sale while an owner can keep paying. The bigger risk for 2021 and 2022 buyers is lower comps and appraisals. Foreclosures and short sales rise when owners with no equity also hit a job loss, divorce or move.

How I got these numbers

  • Owners and purchase prices come from county property records for 329 single-family homes held by institutional rental LLCs. 297 of them mail their tax bills out of state.
  • A home counts as listed only if it showed up in Zillow's for-sale search on November 19, 2026, matched by address and square footage.
  • Sale prices, list prices, price cuts and days on market come from Stellar MLS listing history for 203 homes owned by LLCs named HP, HPA and HPRV that were active, under contract or sold from May to November 2026. Purchase prices come from the deed records on the same reports. Closed sales that haven't been recorded by the county yet still show the prior owner on the property appraiser's site.
  • The 195 of 200 figure matches the HP and HPA homes in the county records to that MLS history by address. Rental and for-sale listing counts by year come from the same history and only count listings after the LLC bought the home.
  • Only 123 of the 329 homes had a usable purchase price. Transfers between related companies for $100 were left out.
  • Asking prices are not sale prices, and listings change. County index figures are from Zillow Research's October 2026 data.

Troy Nowak, Broker of Mangrove Bay Realty (BK3436609)

About the author

Troy Nowak
Troy Nowak

Broker · Mangrove Bay Realty

Troy Nowak is the Broker of Mangrove Bay Realty and a licensed Florida real estate broker. He owns and manages STR and furnished rentals in Pinellas County, is an Airbnb Superhost, and brings former institutional acquisition experience to local buyer and seller decisions. Before real estate, Troy spent a decade as a Pinellas County math teacher and the head varsity basketball coach at Dunedin High, so he knows the neighborhoods, school zones, and what makes Pinellas tick from a lived-in angle. 325+ closings, average $523K, every range from first-time buyers at $117K to waterfront homes at $1.9M.

Broker of Mangrove Bay Realty325+ closingsOwns and manages STR and furnished rentalsAirbnb Superhost/operator experienceFormer institutional acquisition experience
View full bio

Florida Licensed Broker · #BK3436609

Topics in this article

institutional investors FloridaTampa Bay home pricesOrlando home pricesselling below purchase price2022 home buyers

Keep exploring

Top related pages in this topic, ranked by relevance and search demand.

Contact